Skip to main content

The End of Whaling

Whale catcher Sondra leaving a factory ship. Source: John Alexander

The Decline of the Industry

Despite regulations imposed by the International Whaling Commission (IWC) in 1946, whaling continued at unsustainable levels. By the 1960s, the consequences of overexploitation became evident, with many whale populations severely depleted. Some countries, like the United Kingdom and Norway, began to withdraw from the industry due to declining whale stocks and competition from alternative sources of fats and oils. Severe pressure had also built up on antarctic whale stocks. By the 1950s Blue whales were very rare, forcing catchers to sail ever further in search of Antarctic whales.

Save the Whale protest London, 1981 Giant inflatable Whale. Friends of the Earth campaign for an end to the commercial whaling threatening the extinction of whales. Protests such as these were held all over the world. Source: NLA/reportdigital.co.uk

The anti-whaling movement gained momentum in the 1970s, raising public awareness about the plight of whales and the brutality of the whaling industry. The release of ‘Songs of the Humpback Whale’ by Roger Payne, featuring recordings of whale vocalizations, further galvanized public support for whale conservation. Organisations such as Greenpeace began confronting whaling ships in the North Pacific, raising awareness among the public of whaling practises. It led to an understanding among the public that whales were intelligent creatures who lived in their own complex underwater societies.

“There just weren’t enough whales to go round. The whale stocks were going down very steeply and we could see this happening. It didn't require second sight to see that. And so, in 1960, we started talking a view that we had to get out of this and by 1963 we were out completely”

Sir Gerald Elliot, Operational Manager, Christian Salvesen & Co, 1948
The Grytviken whaling station as it looks today. Source: Government of South Georgia & the South Sandwich Islands (GSGSSI)

In 1964, Grytviken whaling station closed for good. The land-based whaling industry on South Georgia finally ended with the closure of the last working factory at Leith Station in 1965. A total of 175,250 whales were killed in the waters around South Georgia. In 1982, the International Whaling Commission voted to pass a moratorium on whaling. The IWC finally implemented a moratorium on commercial whaling in 1986, marking a turning point in the history of whaling. In 1994, the Commission created the Southern Ocean Whale Sanctuary, a 50 million square kilometre area surrounding Antarctica. Hopefully, these measures will see a return to pre-whaling numbers in South Georgia.

Whalers were well aware that whaling was coming to an end and that it would not be able to continue for much longer in the early 1960s. Source: Eric Stevenson

“We knew then, that the 1961 – 1962 season was going to be the last because there weren’t enough whales. We all knew that. We were out of work then. The next year, we had to look for work”

James Yorkston, Mess Boy, 1958

“We had an idea that things weren’t so good…”

Donald Lennie, Engineer, 1959

“It had to come to an end. It was as simple as that”

Geoffrey Smethurst , Radio Operator, 1947

The factory ship Southern Venturer. Source: Frederick John Haines Mackereth

Whale catching in numbers

From the years 1904-1965 there were 175,250 whales caught and processed on South Georgia. This equates to around nine million barrels of whale oil.

With factory ships came a huge increase in the number of whales being caught. By 1930 there were 41 factory ships operating with 232 whaling catchers in the Southern Oceans. The number of whales being killed per year had gone from 14,000 to over 40,000. 

The first whales that were hunted to near extinction were the Southern right whales and Humpback whales. This was due to intensive whaling in the Southern regions before industrial whaling began.

Total whale catch at
South Georgia 1904-1965

Click to toggle On/Off

Humpback Whales 41,515
Fin Whales 87,555
Blue Whales 26,754
Sei Whales 15,128
Sperm Whales 3,716
Southern Right Whales 582
Total: 175,250
"Whale ahoy!" Source: John Alexander

In the Southern Hemisphere, 345,775 Antarctic blue whales were killed between 1904 and 1973. Until 1935 Blue whales were the most targeted species, with the peaking being in 1930/1931 when 30,406 were caught.

Within the South Georgia area, just 359 Antarctic Blue whales were taken by the pelagic fleet, less than 1% of the total. In the early 1900s, South Georgia waters thronged with blue whales; within little over 30 years, they were all but gone.

Number of barrels of whale oil produced at
South Georgia 1904-1965

Click to toggle On/Off

1 barrel = 170 litres / 37.4 imp gallons
Total production at South Georgia 1904-1966 9,360,084 barrels
1,488,134,389 Liters

Whale strike. Source: John Alexander

Catcher crew. Source: Shetland ex-Whalers Association

Respect and reflection

Now in the twenty-first century, attitudes towards whaling have changed. We often reflect on the brutality of the industry, condemning those involved. Without considering the reasons that sent people there to do the job. It is important to reflect on this period with respect for those who travelled so far to find work. Without the income that was generated from the whaling industry, many communities around Scotland would not have survived.

Source: James Yorkston

Whalers reflect on the camaraderie and the relationships that have continued in the decades following on from the end of the whaling. The men who went to South Georgia formed bonds with others that have endured, strengthened by their shared experiences. Connecting people from around the North Sea though from working in South Georgia and on-board factory and catching ships. Since then, clubs and associations have been formed which organised trips and gatherings to bring together whalers. Giving people a chance to reminisce and meet each other’s families.

“If it hadn’t been for that camaraderie, you wouldn’t have been able to get through it”

John Alexander, Electrical Engineer, 1954

 

Source: Shetland ex-Whalers Association

“Nobody thought the way they think now. We’re sure we wouldn’t like to do it now anyway. But then, if you look back, it was needed after the war. That’s according to the history that I’ve read anyway, I may be biased I don’t know. But after the war we needed stuff. There wasn’t any crude oil or anything like that. It was all hard to come by. So, everything got used with the whaling oil. The sperm oil was used for sewing machines and mending things. It was the only oil they could use on a sewing machine”

James Yorkston, Mess Boy, 1958

Jaw of a sperm whale on a flensing plan. Source: John Alexander

“It would be an interesting exercise if a survey was taken to seek the views of ex whalers as to whether they would follow the same destructive path again. I have a feeling there would be very few, if any, when given hindsight. Even though the oils and bi-products were needed in the post war years were they really essential? I am sure the question niggles many. Even at the time many of us were appalled at the suffering and slaughter of defenceless animals but somehow we got on with it. If, given the chance, I think most of us would like to experience the Antarctic wilderness again as long as it wasn’t to help in the killing”

George Moar, Deck Mess Boy, Southern Venturer, 1947

Scrapheap at Leith Harbour. Source: John Alexander

“I enjoyed the work to start with. But the camaraderie and being at sea, was something else. But that was a different kind of being at sea. I could have gone on cruise ships and had a great life. I knew a guy who did that, but he always came home skint because he spent all his money. I enjoyed being at sea and I would have stayed longer. Some of the guys were there in 1946, and they were still there in 1963. That is a long time. I only did four seasons. I would have still been there it had still been going – as long as they would have had me”

Donald Lennie, Engineer, 1959

Source: Alister Thomason

"Explosion". Source: John Alexander

The Legacy of Whaling and the Future of Whales

The history of whaling in the Antarctic is a stark reminder of the consequences of overexploitation. Millions of whales were killed, pushing many species to the brink of extinction. While some populations, like humpback whales, are showing signs of recovery, others remain endangered or vulnerable.

Humpback whale bubble net feeding. Source: Christin Khan, NOAA

The future of whales in the antarctic faces continued challenges from climate change and human activities. Climate change is impacting the distribution and abundance of krill, the primary food source for many baleen whales. Other threats include entanglement in fishing gear, ship strikes, and noise pollution. The impacts that these challenges have on biodiversity in the antarctic is not yet fully understood.

The conservation of whales in the antarctic requires ongoing monitoring, research, and international cooperation to mitigate these threats and ensure the long-term survival of these magnificent creatures. Through tracking their migratory, feeding and mating patterns, we can gain an understanding of their impact on the local ecosystem. Visitors to the region can also help by reporting sightings and injustices committed against whales and other marine species.

Artist's impresson of the whale memorial, Commensalis. Source: Michael Visocchi and Adam Proctor

A new whale memorial in South Georgia will commemorate the number of whales caught and processed on the island. This will be installed on the flensing plan in Grytviken, the central point for all the whale processing. The catch from Grytviken whaling station represents 29.45% of all the whales caught in the regions during the 60 years of whaling at South Georgia.

View the Memorial

Sunrise at Leith Harbour. Source: John Alexander